DOI: 10.46340/eujem.2024.10.3.3
Mykola Polovyi, D.Sc. in Political Science
Copernicus University, Bratislava
How to cite: Polovyi, M. (2024). Simulation Model of the Formation and Development of the All-Russian Agrarian Commodity Market in the Second Half of the 18th – Early 20th Century. European Journal of Economics and Management, 10, 3, 18-26. https://doi.org/10.46340/eujem.2024.10.3.3
Abstract
The paper analyzes the model of the grain balance’s dynamics in different regions and assesses the efficiency and development of the grain market during 18-19 centuries. It is stated, that in the context of annual grain transportation the overall yearly import and export of grain to and from a region are influenced by the surplus and shortage of grain in various areas. Regions with more than 5% surplus of grain are identified as exporting regions, while those with more than 5% shortage are identified as importing regions. Among the main factors affecting grain trade are the model accounts, the transportation distance, transportation capabilities, epidemic situations, money supply sufficiency, government trade policies, and international trade conditions. The model’s effectiveness was tested by comparing model-derived optimal trade scenarios with actual historical data over a 55-year period (1802-1856). It is stated, that the model was found to adequately describe the grain export dynamics to foreign countries in at least 72% of cases. Regional grain balances in 18-19 centuries were assessed. It is revealed, that grain production and consumption varied greatly due to unstable agricultural yields and changing population demands. Surplus grain was often exported even from regions with overall negative grain balances by reducing local consumption or using lower-quality substitutes. Market development over time characterized with the features: 1) from the 1830s onwards, there was a noticeable improvement in the grain market as more regions could consistently export grain, leading to a more interconnected market; 2) by the late 19th century, interregional grain trade became more active, indicating a well-developed market. The comparison between the optimal model and actual historical data helps identify discrepancies and understand the development level of the grain market. It is proved, that the model’s strength lies in its ability to work with estimated values and limited precise data, providing a robust tool for historical economic analysis.
Keywords: simulation model, model of agrarian market, grain prices, factors of economic dynamics, social impact of the grain market.
JEL: N 55, D02, C 63.
References
Arkhangelsky, G. I. (1874). Holernyie epidemii v Evropeyskoy Rossii v 50-tiletniy period 1823-1872 gg. [Cholera Epidemics in European Russia in the 50-year Period 1823-1872]. St. Petersburg. [in Russian].
Arsenyev, K. (1848). Statisticheskie ocherki Rossii [Statistical Essays on Russia]. St. Petersburg. [in Russian].
Beveridge, W.H. (1965). Prices and Wages in England from the Twelfth to the Nineteenth Century. London.
Chen J., and Roth J. (2024) Logs with Zeros? Some Problems and SolutionsGet access Arrow. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, V. 139, Iss. 2, 891–936, https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjad054
Derbek, F. A. (1905). Istoriya chumnyih epidemiy v Rossii s osnovaniya gosudarstva do nastoyaschego vremeni [History of Plague Epidemics in Russia from the Foundation of the State to the Present]. St. Petersburg, 215-366. [in Russian].
Drobizhev, V.Z., Kovalchenko, I.D., Muravyov, A.V. (1973). Istoricheskaya geografiya SSSR [Historical Geography of the USSR]. Moscow, 167-262. [in Russian].
Fortunatov, A. (1893). Urozhai rzhi v Evropeyskoy Rossii [Rye Harvests in European Russia]. Moscow, 81-93. [in Russian].
Friis, A., Glamann, K. (1958). A History of Prices and Wages in Denmark. 1660-1800. Toronto, 1.
Georgievskiy, P. N. (1885). Mezhdunarodnaya hlebnaya torgovlya [International Grain Trade]. St. Petersburg, 1. [in Russian].
Istomina, E. G. (1982). Vodnyie puti Rossii vo vtoroy polovine XVIII – nachale XIXvv. [Waterways of Russia in the Second Half of the 18th – early 19th Centuries]. Moscow: Sciense. [in Russian].
Kabuzan, V.M. (1971). Izmeneniya v razmeschenii naseleniya Rossii v XVIII-pervoy polovine XIX vv. [Changes in the Distribution of the Population of Russia in the 18th – First Half of the 19th Centuries]. Moscow. [in Russian].
Kashkarov, M. (1898). Denezhnoe obraschenie v Rossii (Istoriko-statisticheskoe issledovanie) [Money Circulation in Russia. (Historical and Statistical Study)]. St. Petersburg. [in Russian].
Kaufman, I. I. (1909). Iz istorii bumazhnyih deneg v Rossii [From the history of paper money in Russia]. St. Petersburg. [in Russian].
Kitanina, T. M. (1987). Hlebnaya torgovlya Rossii v 1875-1914gg. (Ocherki pravitelstvennoy politiki) [Grain Trade in Russia in 1875-1914. (Essays on Government Policy)]. Science. [in Russian].
Lodyzhensky, K. P. (1886). Istoriya russkogo tamozhennogo tarifa [History of the Russian Customs Tariff]. St. Petersburg. [in Russian].
Mikhailovsky, V.G. (1921) Urozhai v Rossii s 1801 po 1914gg [Harvests in Russia from 1801 to 1914].
Byulleten Tsentralnogo statisticheskogo upravleniya [Bulletin of the Central Statistical Office]. N50. P.2-5. [in Russian]
Mironov, B.N. (1985). Hlebnyie tsenyi v Rossii za dva stoletiya (XVIII-XIXvv.) [Grain Prices in Russia for Two Centuries (XVIII-XIX Centuries)], 34-35. [in Russian].
Nebolsin, G. (1850). Statisticheskoe obozrenie vneshney torgovli Rossii [Statistical Review of Russia’s Foreign Trade]. St. Petersburg. [in Russian].
Polovyi, M. (2023a) Peculiarities of the functioning of regional grain markets during the modernization transit European Journal of Economics and Management, 2023, V. 9, Iss. 5, 5-13. https://doi.org/10.46340/eujem.2023.9.5.1
Polovyi, M. (2023b) Specific features of the methodology for applying correlation and variance analysis to study the formation of the grain market in the capitalist era. European Journal of Economics and Management, 2023, V. 9, Iss. 4. 5-13. https://doi.org/10.46340/eujem.2023.9.4.1
Posthumus, N.W. (1943). Nederlandsche prijsgeschiedenis [Dutch Price History]. Leiden [in Dutch].
Rashin, A.G. (1956). Naselenie Rossii za 100 let, 1811-1913 gg. Statisticheskie ocherki [Population of Russia for 100 years, 1811-1913. Statistical Essays]. Moscow. [in Russian].
Rogers, J.E.T. (1902). A History of Agriculture and Prices in England. Oxford, 7.
Sbornik svedeniy po istorii i statistike vneshney torgovli Rossii [Collection of Information on the History and Statistics of Russia’s Foreign Trade]. (1902). St. Petersburg, II, III. [in Russian].
Slovtsov, P.A. (1858). Istoricheskoe i statisticheskoe obozrenie neurozhaev v Rossii [Historical and Statistical Review of Crop Failures in Russia]. In: Sbornik statisticheskih svedeniy o Rossii [Collection of Statistical Information about Russia]. St. Petersburg, 3, 465-502. [in Russian].
Tooke, T. (1824). Thoughts and Details of the High and Low Prices of the Thirty Years from 1793 to 1822. London.
Tooke, T., Newmarch, W. (1838-1857). A History of Prices and the State of the Circulation. London, 1-6.
Vodarsky, Ya.E. (1973). Naselenie Rossii za 400 let, XV-nachalo XX v. [Population of Russia for 400 years,
16th – early 20th Centuries]. Moscow. [in Russian].
Yatsunsky, V.K. (1957). Izmeneniya v razmeschenii naseleniya Evropeyskoy Rossii v 1724-1916 gg. [Changes in the Distribution of the Population of European Russia in 1724-1916]. Istorya SSSR [History of the USSR], 1, 192-224. [in Russian].